Frederic Neyrat on Thu, 17 Aug 2017 06:51:42 +0200 (CEST)

[Date Prev] [Date Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: <nettime> Who said the US is boring?

Dear Brian,

Like you, I don't see any organization able to do this coup. But what seems to me very important is to understand that, IF there is a strategy at stake in Trump's politics, this is not a democratic one:

1/ First, is there a strategy at stake, and not only random tweets and volte-faces? I think it's better to think that there is a strategy rather than none or rather than just highlighting Trump's psychosis. Actually there is no contradiction between these two features - strategy, and psychosis or let's say primary narcissism à la Freud - but we should rather think that there is - what, a political will, a political drive, an inchoate strategy? Something like that;

2/ So let's call it the Strategy T. 
Hypothetical, but theoretically useful;

3/ The important point for me is to affirm that Strategy T is not democratic. The goal is to find a way to suspend democracy/civil rights/freedom/next elections etc. Whatever the means. War, "terrorist" attack, financial crisis, etc. We all know what the "shock doctrine" is;

4/ So of course the Strategy T does not aim to use white suprematists to win any election, for that's not the goal. The goal is to create the conditions thanks to which democracy could be suspended. Bannon recently declared that they are "clowns" (sic):
The problem is that clowns can be furiously dangerous - even and especially when they don't exist (or feel like on the verge of vanishing from the scene of History (in memoriam Hegel));

5/Then (I refer here to another email of Brian) "molecular" battles could happen, micro civil wars and so on: all these events would be a perfect reason to suspend the US democracy. Here again, the understanding of the situation is located in the articulation between the molecular level (the "Bruce Willis movies" as you say) and the institutional one (the sudden legitimization of the Strategy T);

The only thing that could prevent that coup is the "crumbling" situation - as you noticed - generated by Trump's "administration" of the country. In fact, the man in the high castle cannot win against the people - especially if the capitalists do not support him any longer because they risk losing too much (money). Fascism without capitalism is not possible. 

In this respect, there is one positive thing in the US situation: the necessity to take side, to express what the important values/ideas are. Thanks to that, maybe a sort of interesting political division could rise up, a division that would really be political (and not racial, based on resentment or liars, etc.). My drop of optimism.



2017-08-16 12:14 GMT-07:00 Brian Holmes <>:
Well, I have said so myself in the past. But it doesn't seem that way today. Right now you have the entire punditocracy and even the Prez hisself debating whether White Supremacy is to blame for the nation's ills. Monuments to the slaveholding Confederacy that were put up long after its demise are being taken down secretly in a single night, after agonized moral debate in the city councils, followed by raw fear that the Nazis might come to your town. As for the latter, they have declared a "Summer of Hate" in an uncanny rejoinder to some dazed celebrations 50 years ago. It all kind of momentarily overshadows the worry that the North Koreans might splash Guam with an improvised ICBM, or that a rash move by a would-be Commander-in-Chief might unleash a sea of fire on the peaceful city of Seoul.

On one level, this is profoundly boring, as people across the planet will likely agree. Everyone is transfixed by a media system that promised a "Knowledge Society" but now focuses exclusively on a pathetic narcissist given to cathartic emotional outbursts. The major problems remain unaddressed, like what to do about a collapsing geopolitical system, or the coming wave of unemployment caused by AI, or above all, the currently unfurling mass extinction event and the explosive climate catastrophes spurred on by rising CO2 emissions. Beneath the 24-hour forth of the news, much of the regulatory apparatus built up by generations  of Americans to protect both the population and the environment from capitalist rapacity is being pragmatically stripped away. What's paid no attention today is defining tomorrow.

On the other hand we in fact are debating White Supremacy, arguably the cultural bedrock on which imperial, extractive, consequence-denying capitalism has been built. With his declarations yesterday, Trump became the Defender-in-Chief of White Supremacy. The result is that his administration is crumbling, his closest advisors are speechless, the upper crust of the corporate sector is peeling away, and it's down to the hard core of the radical white nationalists and the most aggressive elements in the oil-and-gas industry, the military and the police. Things could go quick now. The outbreak of war followed by mass protests, or simply another incident with a car barreling down a city street, could unleash confrontations between ordinary citizens and armed diehards raised on survivalism and Bruce Willis movies. If the Fearless Leader were more competent, such a scenario would be the chance for a coup and a real KKK fascist USA. But I don't see evidence for any organization coherent enough to do such a thing. Instead it's likely to be a fearful ugly mess with further opportunities for entropic social decay and stealth militarization of the status quo.

Fellow citizens, indigenous sovereignists and proud illegals, let's say something different to the world.


#  distributed via <nettime>: no commercial use without permission
#  <nettime>  is a moderated mailing list for net criticism,
#  collaborative text filtering and cultural politics of the nets
#  more info:
#  archive: contact:
#  @nettime_bot tweets mail w/ sender unless #ANON is in Subject:

#  distributed via <nettime>: no commercial use without permission
#  <nettime>  is a moderated mailing list for net criticism,
#  collaborative text filtering and cultural politics of the nets
#  more info:
#  archive: contact:
#  @nettime_bot tweets mail w/ sender unless #ANON is in Subject: